News

The Street Urchins in London and the Cinna the Poet Moment


By Sola Adeola
Beyond the Headlines. Beneath the Surface.

Governance | Security | Criminology | Public Policy | Strategic Communication

Tel: 08033141980 Bluelines Communications Limited

Honestly, the London episode deserves a comedy award. I have been wondering what exactly went through the minds of some of these protesters. How do you travel all the way to London to make a political statement, armed with placards, rehearsed slogans and righteous indignation, only for a photograph circulating around the controversy to be wrongly identified?

Imagine the scene. You have prepared your placards, rehearsed your chants, put on your best London accent and perhaps even practised shouting your slogans with the appropriate British intonation. Then comes a photograph of Tunde Doherty, and some people confidently identify him as Professor Joash Amupitan, the INEC Chairman.

Kai! What a spectacular own goal!

One would have thought that establishing the identity of the person in the photograph would be the easiest part of the exercise. But apparently, that little detail escaped the preparation committee. Everything was ready except the facts.

I could not help remembering William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, particularly the unfortunate story of Cinna the Poet.

For those who may have forgotten their literature, Cinna the Poet appears in Act III, Scene III. Following Caesar’s assassination, an angry Roman mob is hunting for the conspirators. Unfortunately, it encounters a poet who shares a name with Cinna the conspirator.

They ask him his name.

“Cinna,” he replies.

That is all the mob needs to hear. When he explains that he is a poet, not the conspirator they are looking for, they refuse to listen. His explanation makes no difference. They decide that he must pay simply because he bears the same name as the man they want. They eventually tear him to pieces.

Just imagine! A man goes out as a poet and ends up paying for somebody else’s identity.

Now, what if our London protesters had taken their mistaken-identity drama a little further? Tunde Doherty could have become the Cinna the Poet of our own political comedy, an unsuspecting man caught in the crossfire of other people’s anger simply because somebody failed to establish his identity.

Thank goodness we were spared such a Shakespearean tragedy. It is one thing to make a fool of yourself on social media. It is quite another to expose an unconnected person to hostility.

The lesson is simple. Before you confront anybody, make sure you have found the right person. Shakespeare understood, centuries ago, that a mob driven by anger rather than reason can become dangerous.

But wait. The London comedy has another interesting dimension. It is not just the mistaken identity. It is also the vocabulary some of these protesters have chosen to describe President Bola Ahmed Tinubu.

Suddenly, everybody has become a lawyer. The President is called an Olóṣò, an ex-convict and virtually every other name that can be squeezed into a protest chant.

Ex-convict!

I actually find this one amusing. Do these people understand what the expression means? An ex-convict is someone who has previously been convicted of a criminal offence. It is not a convenient political insult to pick up whenever you run out of arguments.

There is a difference between an allegation, an investigation, a civil forfeiture proceeding, a criminal prosecution and a criminal conviction. These are distinct legal concepts. They do not become interchangeable simply because somebody is angry with the President.

The often-cited 1993 United States civil forfeiture proceedings involving funds held in accounts associated with Tinubu are part of the public record and deserve scrutiny. But a civil forfeiture proceeding and its outcome should not automatically be described as a criminal conviction of the person associated with the funds. Legal language matters, particularly when making serious allegations against another person.

You may disagree with Tinubu. You may dislike his policies, criticise his appointments, challenge his economic decisions and demand accountability. Nobody is stopping you. That is what democracy is about. But you cannot manufacture a criminal conviction with a placard. Neither can you turn an allegation into a judicial finding by shouting it repeatedly.

The same goes for the Olóṣò label. What exactly is the argument? Is that now the standard vocabulary of political engagement? When insults become the substance of a protest, one begins to wonder whether the message has run out of ideas.

There is also an irony worth mentioning. Some of those who readily throw such insults from London have made another man’s country their home. There is absolutely nothing wrong with seeking a better life abroad. Nigerians in the diaspora contribute enormously to their families and to the country. But living in London does not automatically confer a certificate of superior patriotism.

You can live abroad and still love Nigeria. You can live in Nigeria and be deeply critical of its government. The issue is not where you live. It is whether your criticism is informed, fair and responsible. A loud voice and an imported accent are not substitutes for facts.

My concern is that political discourse is increasingly becoming a competition in name-calling. Every allegation is treated as an established fact. Every disagreement becomes an opportunity for abuse. Every photograph is accepted as evidence, even when the person in it has been wrongly identified.

And when the truth eventually emerges, everybody simply moves on as if nothing happened.

Let me make something clear. Nigerians living abroad have every right to protest against their government. They can question INEC, demand electoral credibility and insist that public officials account for their actions. Nobody should confuse legitimate protest with an attempt to silence dissent.

But the right to protest does not come with a licence to abandon common sense. If you want to hold somebody accountable, first establish who that person is. If you want to accuse somebody of a crime, understand the law and produce evidence.

You cannot be looking for Professor Amupitan and end up identifying Tunde Doherty. You cannot demand accountability while failing the most basic test of identification. And you certainly cannot turn the word ex-convict into a political nickname.

Honestly, the London episode has provided enough material for a comedy series. The placards were ready, the voices were loud, but the facts were apparently on holiday.

Perhaps somebody should remind these protesters that political activism is not a shouting competition. Neither is London a theatre where every loud performance deserves applause.

Before you bark, know who you are barking at. Before you throw labels around, understand what they mean. And before you demand somebody’s resignation, make sure you have found the person whose resignation you are demanding.

Otherwise, you may travel all the way to London, organise a protest, raise your placards and return home with nothing more than a spectacular case of mistaken identity.

Shakespeare gave us Cinna the Poet. London almost gave us another version.

The trouble with political activism without facts is that, sometimes, the only thing being exposed is the intellectual poverty of the activists themselves.

And in another episode of Nigerian political theatre, the ADC has reportedly received a phone call from beyond the grave, with Buhari allegedly requesting that his 12 million votes be transferred to the party. Apparently, even in the great beyond, voter registration and political realignment remain unfinished business. Who says Nigerian politics ever runs out of surprises?



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *