Blue Silks: Lawyers ask court to dismiss objections in suit against Supreme Court Chief Registrar's petition

Nigerian non-litigation lawyers have insisted that the National Industrial Court of Nigeria has the jurisdiction to hear a suit challenging a petition against the Blue Silks rank, filed before the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee, LPDC, by the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, Mr Kabir Akanbi.
Akanbi had in the petition sought sanctions on legal practitioners who were conferred with the Blue Silks rank, which was introduced by the Association of Legislative Drafting Practitioners, ALDRAP, as an alternative to the Senior Advocate of Nigeria, SAN, title for non-litigation lawyers.
The suit, numbered NICN/ABJ/363/2026, has the non-litigation lawyers, under the aegis of Incorporated Trustees of Association of Legislative Drafting Practitioners, ALDRAP, and its Executive Secretary, Dr Tonye Clinton Jaja, as plaintiffs. The respondents are LPDC, Body of Benchers, Akanbi and the Federal Judicial Service Commission, FJSC.
The lawyers are asking the industrial court to declare that the decision of the LPDC to accept, entertain and proceed with the petition filed by Akanbi against the plaintiffs is unconstitutional, ultra vires, unlawful, null and void, and in violation of sections 36(6), 36(9) and 36(12) of the Constitution and Rules 32 and 33 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, 2023.
The suit came up before the National Industrial Court in Abuja on November 16.
The respondents, through the law firm of Dr. Wale Babalakin, SAN, counsel to Akanbi, the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, have filed a preliminary objection, arguing that the National Industrial Court has no jurisdiction to hear the lawsuit.
However, the lawyers to ALDRAP and Jaja – who are promoters of the Blue Silks rank of Senior Counsel of Nigeria, SCN – have in their counter-arguments asked the court to dismiss the respondents' preliminary objections, insisting that the industrial court has the jurisdiction to hear the suit.
The counsel for the plaintiffs argued that both Section 254c of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (Third Alteration) and a long line of decided cases by Nigerian courts have established that the National Industrial Court of Nigeria has jurisdiction in issues involving human rights in the workplace (fundamental rights enforcement of Chapter IV of the Nigerian Constitution specifically connected to employment and labour issues).
Parts of the plaintiffs' counter-motion read, "In this instance, the Incorporated Trustees is seeking an Order of the Honourable Court to apply the September 2026 judgment in the Chief JK Gadzama's case to find that the relevant provisions of the Legal Practitioners Act, 1962 under which the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee, LPDC, proceeded to entertain and make a decision to continue hearing a petition filed against the Applicant/Plaintiff is a violation of Section 36(1) of the Nigerian Constitution to the extent that it, the Legal Practitioners Act, 1962, does not provide any mechanism for appeals against the decisions of the LPDC.
"Also, Section 254c of the Nigerian Constitution confers jurisdiction upon the National Industrial Court of Nigeria to hear and determine appeals arising from the decisions of administrative tribunals and panels such as the LPDC.
"Section 254c of the Nigerian Constitution confers jurisdiction upon the National Industrial Court of Nigeria to hear and determine cases involving employees and employers such as the 3rd and 4th Defendants in this current lawsuit wherein Mr. Kabir Eniola Akanbi, Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, is being sued as the 3rd Defendant and his employer, the Federal Judicial Service Commission, is being sued as the 4th Defendant.
"The Applicants/Claimant is suing to request the Honourable Court to issue a declaration to compel the employer, 4th Defendant to pay only half-salary to the 3rd Defendant, Mr. Kabir Eniola Akanbi because he is spending more than 50 percent of his working hours in his capacity as Secretary to the Legal Practitioners Privileges Committee, LPPC, instead of giving full time attention to his full-time employment as an employee of the Federal Judicial Service Commission.
"Section 254c of the Nigerian Constitution confers jurisdiction upon the National Industrial Court of Nigeria to hear and determine cases involving unfair labour practices and discrimination. In this instance case, the Applicant/Plaintiff is seeking the Orders of the Honourable Court to protect both themselves and members of the 1st Applicant's organisation from the discrimination and unfair trial by the LPDC based on a petition by the 3rd Defendant, Mr. Kabir Eniola Akanbi."
The non-litigation lawyers further argued that one of the grounds for alleging discrimination and likelihood of bias is that by virtue of the dual office he occupies as Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court of Nigeria and the Secretary of the Legal Practitioners Privileges Committee, LPPC, Akanbi is both directly and indirectly a member of the said LPDC.
"Also, in terms of unfair practices within the labour market of lawyers in Nigeria, both Applicants and Plaintiffs have in a separate petition which is annexed as Exhibit provided evidence that the Defendant is allegedly involved in unfair and discriminatory practices within the Nigerian labour market of professional ranks of legal excellence for lawyers and is using (misusing) its dominant position to perpetuate monopoly and bully competitors such as the plaintiffs who are seeking to promote the Blue Silks rank of Senior Counsel of Nigeria-SCN," they added.
In addition to a declaration that it was illegal for the LPDC to entertain the petition filed by Akanbi against lawyers associated with the Blue Silks rank, the plaintiffs also asked the National Industrial Court to issue an order quashing the decision of the LPDC to accept and entertain the petition. The court was equally asked to issue a prohibition order restraining the LPDC from going ahead with the petition, as well as an order restraining Akanbi from implementing, enforcing or publishing the said decision, until the applicants are provided with an avenue to exercise their constitutional right of appeal.
In the same vein, the industrial court was asked to issue an order of perpetual injunction restraining Akanbi from ever submitting a petition against the plaintiffs and any other Nigerian lawyer on the issue of the Blue Silks rank of Senior Counsel of Nigeria, SCN, for the entire period that he remains in office as secretary of the LPDC and Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court of Nigeria.
The plaintiffs are also seeking an order of perpetual injunction restraining the LPDC from entertaining any petition from Akanbi concerning the Blue Silks rank.
