Court nullifies substitution of Abia APC senatorial candidate's name, affirms Erondu Jr. as winner

The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed Erondu Uchenna Erondu Jnr. as the authentic and duly elected candidate of the All Progressives Congress , APC, for Abia South Senatorial District in the 2027 general elections.
The judgment, which was delivered on Wednesday by Justice M. Umar, upheld Erondu’s victory in the APC senatorial primary election conducted on May 18, 2026, and nullified the alleged substitution of Erondu's name with Prince Paul Ikonne.
The suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1503/2026, Erondu v. All Progressives Congress & 4 Others, arose from the controversy surrounding the party’s revised list of senatorial candidates submitted to the Independent National Electoral Commission, INEC.
Erondu, who currently represents Obingwa-West State Constituency in the Abia State House of Assembly, had emerged the winner of the primary election with 15,982 votes, according to the APC Senatorial Primary Election Declaration of Result Form dated May 18, 2026.
Other contestants included Dr Blessing Nwagba, who secured 4,556 votes; Prince Paul Ikonne, who polled 4,322 votes; and Nyerere Chinenye Anyim, who garnered 4,022 votes.
Following his emergence, however, controversy erupted over the party’s senatorial nomination after reports emerged that his name had been substituted with that of Prince Paul Ikonne in the APC’s revised list of candidates submitted to INEC.
Dissatisfied with the development, Erondu approached the Federal High Court in Abuja, challenging the alleged substitution and seeking legal protection for the mandate he secured through the party’s primary election.
He maintained that he was duly elected, had neither voluntarily withdrawn from the contest nor been lawfully disqualified, insisting that the party’s internal nomination process and the will of its members must be respected.
In his judgment, Justice Umar held that a political party is bound to forward the name of an aspirant who emerges victorious through a valid primary election to INEC and cannot arbitrarily substitute such a candidate without lawful justification.
Relying on established judicial authorities, the court maintained that once a political party has made its choice through a valid primary election, it has no discretion to replace the successful aspirant or conduct another primary election without a legally tenable reason.
Consequently, the court made five key orders, declaring Erondu the APC candidate for the 2027 Abia South Senatorial District election; affirming that he had not withdrawn his nomination; and ruling that the party could not substitute him with Prince Paul Ikonne.
The court also restrained INEC from acting on APC's purported substitution of Erondu and directed the electoral commission to publish his name, address and particulars as the party's candidate for the election.
Speaking shortly after the judgment in Abuja, an elated Erondu described the verdict as an act of God, expressing gratitude to the judiciary and party leaders who stood by him throughout the legal battle.
Court nullifies substitution of Abia APC senatorial candidate’s name, affirms Erondu Jr. as winner
